When It Comes to Israel, Ignorant Actors, Like Leonard Nimoy Should Keep Their Mouths Shut…Divide Jerusalem?…That is Not Logical!!

Written by Marty Roberts on June 10, 2011 – 10:51 am -

Why do actors think that they are qualified to engage in international diplomacy???

Leonard Nimoy

Leonard Nimoy

Since when does being very famous and being very good at pretending to be someone that you are not in a situation that is not real in front of a camera or on stage…since when does that qualify you as an expert on international affairs? Why should anyone give an actor any more credence than a plumber (no offense to plumbers…I respect THEM more than I do actors…they do something MUCH more useful to society) when it comes to their opinion on international issues (that they usually know nothing about)???

Nimoy, you may be Jewish, but you do NOT live in Israel, you do NOT have any particular knowledge about events in the Middle East, neither you nor you children serve in the Israeli Army, and you are not even particularly identified as being Jewish or caring about Israel, even if your Vulcan hand signal is an imitation of the Jewish priests’ hand position while blessing the Jewish people (you probably didn’t even know that)…

So, when it comes to your efforts for “peace” in Israel…please keep them to yourself and your family and close friends…

‘Spock’ calls for Jerusalem’s division

Jewish actor Leonard Nimoy known for famous Star Trek role writes letter on ‘Americans for Peace Now’ website supporting two-state solution

Reprinted from

The Americans for Peace Now (APN) organization published Tuesday a letter written by actor Leonard Nimoy, best known for his role as Spock in the original Star Trek series and movies, in which the actor supports the establishment of a two-state solution.

The 80-year-old actor called upon the American people to support the peace initiative.

“I reach out to you as someone who is troubled to see the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians continue apparently without an end in sight,” Nimoy wrote.

“In fact, there is an end in sight. It’s known as the two-state solution – a secure, democratic Israel as the Jewish State alongside an independent Palestinian state. Even Israel’s nationalist Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, has come to see this as the shape of the future. The problem is how to reach that end point. It’s something we should be concerned about – not only as world citizens, but as Americans.”

He went on to write that he supports the division of Jerusalem, mentioning 50 other prominent Israelis, including former heads of the Mossad, the Shin Bet and the military who support a two-state solution.

“There is a sizable number of influential voices in Israel saying the same thing… a call for two states for two nations. Their plan includes a Palestinian state alongside Israel with agreed-upon land swaps. The Palestinian-populated areas of Jerusalem would become the capital of Palestine; the Jewish-populated areas the capital of Israel.”

“I’m a strong supporter of APN and the work it does,” Nimoy wrote. “Peace Now’s activities and programs… keep peace on the world’s agenda… Like those Israelis who issued the peace plan, the members of Peace Now have their boots on the ground. They serve in Israel’s military reserves and see every day what life is like without a negotiated peace with the Palestinians.”

Nimoy also addressed the Itamar massacre and the increase in violence in the Middle East.

“A Jewish family was murdered in the West Bank and a woman was killed in a bus bombing in Jerusalem. A rocket attack on southern Israel from the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip resulted in a school bus being hit and a teen died of his wounds. Israel, in turn, has retaliated,” he said.

He added that a strong American leadership is needed to “pivot from the zero-sum mentality of violence to an attitude that focuses on the parties shared interests: Security and prosperity.” Paraphrasing his famous Star Trek quote: “Live long and prosper.”

Nimoy recalled a Star Trek episode called, “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield,” in which the Enterprise runs into “two men, half black, half white, are the last survivors of their peoples who have been at war with each other for thousands of years, yet the Enterprise crew could find no differences separating these two raging men… And they were prepared to battle to the death to defend the memory of their people who died from the atrocities committed by the other.”

The actor attempted to convince the American people to act by supporting the APN, mostly through donations, in order to help resolve the conflict.

“I’m a strong supporter of APN and the work it does. It is a leading voice for Americans who support Israel and know that a negotiated peace will ensure Israel’s security, prosperity and continued viability as a Jewish and democratic state,” wrote Nimoy.

Nimoy stressed he does not intend to belittle the issues that divide Israelis and Palestinians.

“What I do mean to suggest is that the time for recriminations is over. Assigning blame over all other priorities is self-defeating. Myth can be a snare. The two sides need our help to evade the snare and search for a way to compromise,” he said.

The actor also noted how the tumultuous situation in the Middle East has a direct effect on the US economy.

“We’ve seen oil prices rise sharply and America become involved militarily in Libya. The cost to American lives and our economy continues to rise at a time when unemployment and deficits are sapping our country’s strength.”

Nimoy explained that it is also in the interest of the US “to spread the message that there is a peace solution, and to let Congress and the White House know it’s preferable for America to be part of the solution than to be drawn into another conflict.”

Tags: , , , , ,
Posted in American Jews, Celebrities, International, Jerusalem, Jewish People, Palestinians, Peace Talks, United States | 4 Comments »

4 Comments to “When It Comes to Israel, Ignorant Actors, Like Leonard Nimoy Should Keep Their Mouths Shut…Divide Jerusalem?…That is Not Logical!!”

  1. B H Says:

    Hey there,
    Leonard Nimoy actually has a long history of being involve in Jewish activism. The Vulcan greeting was his idea and was deliberately based on the Rabbi’s blessing. You berate him for voicing his opinion because he is a celebrity and claim he’s not qualified to voice said opinion, yet you seem entirely ignorant in your opinions of Mr Nimoy. How can you state that he has no right to an opinion on the future of Israel when you’ve clearly not done any research into his possible qualifications? For all you know, he may have a doctorate in Middle Eastern Politics and Studies. For someone who utilizes to internet to share their opinions with others, I would hopefully assume you are familiar with how to use a search engine.

  2. Marty Roberts Says:

    In spite of the greatnes of Google, my opinion still stands. I am not lacking any of the info you pointed out above. (BTW, the priestly blessing has nothing to do with Rabbis…it is delivered by the Kohanim, the ritual priests of Judaism)
    Nimoy does not appear to have a degree in ME studies of any sort, and no doctorates, either. My shows are well-researched…my opinions well thought out if at times controversial.

    I DO appreciate you taking the time to read my posts and comment.

    Thank you.

  3. Will Says:

    Nimoy is right. He sugar coated it, though. Israel just needs to start acting right and then maybe the Palestinians will start acting right. It is not going to be easy, but in the long run it will work out.

  4. Marty Roberts Says:

    I think that you have the “chicken before the egg” dilemma mixed up. Nimoy is totally wrong and misguided. Israel only WISHES that the palestinians were serious about their desire for a state and peace with Israel, rather than their REAL desire to just continue to suck at the international tit for all their needs while working towards the total destruction of the Jewish State…

Leave a Comment

Submit my blog Lifestyle